Close-up of a woman's eye with sunlight on her face.

5 Makeup Tips for Sensitive Eyes | San Francisco Optometrist

October 03, 20254 min read
Custom HTML/CSS/JAVASCRIPT


Living in San Francisco means dealing with unique environmental factors, from the gusty winds whipping off the bay to the seasonal pollen that blankets our beautiful neighborhoods. For many, this can lead to increased eye sensitivity, making wearing makeup a daily struggle. If you’ve ever experienced red, itchy, or watery eyes after applying mascara or eyeliner, you’re not alone.

We sat down with Dr. Michelle Blas, a leading optometrist at Eyes in Disguise right here on Union St in Cow Hollow, to get her expert advice. Here are her top five tips for wearing makeup without irritation.

Tip 1: Choose the Right Products

The first step to happy eyes is being selective about your products. Many mainstream cosmetics are packed with fragrances, preservatives, and oils that can clog the delicate glands around your eyes, leading to irritation.

"Look for products labeled 'hypoallergenic,' 'fragrance-free,' and 'ophthalmologist-tested,'" advises Dr. Michelle Blas. Cream-based eyeshadows are often a better choice than powders, as they have less fallout that can get into your eyes.

Tip 2: Practice Good Hygiene


Bacteria can build up quickly on makeup brushes and in cosmetic products. This is a common cause of eye infections and irritation.

  • Wash Your Brushes:Clean your makeup brushes, especially those used around the eyes, at least once a week.

  • Replace Products Regularly:Pay attention to expiration dates. Mascara and liquid eyeliner should be replaced every three months, without exception.

  • Never Share:Sharing eye makeup is one of the fastest ways to spread bacteria.

Close-up of an eye with black eyeliner being applied.

Tip 3: Master Gentle Application and Removal

How you apply and remove your makeup is just as important as the products you use. Avoid applying eyeliner to your inner lash line (the waterline), as this can block important oil glands and introduce bacteria directly into your eye.

When it's time to take your makeup off, use a gentle, oil-free remover specifically designed for eyes. Instead of scrubbing, press a soaked cotton pad to your closed eyelid for about 30 seconds to dissolve the makeup before gently wiping it away.

Tip 4: Give Your Eyes a Break

Just like you need a day off, so do your eyes. Try to go makeup-free at least one or two days a week. This gives your eyes and the sensitive skin around them a chance to breathe and recover, reducing the risk of chronic dryness and irritation. This simple step can make a huge difference, especially for those who spend long hours in front of screens.

Close-up of a woman's face with green eyes and natural makeup.

Tip 5: Get Expert, Personalized Advice

While these tips can provide immediate relief, understanding the specific cause of your sensitivity is key. To help her patients, Dr. Michelle Blas has developed an in-depth guide with product recommendations and a list of toxic ingredients to avoid.

For more comprehensive tips, download the FREE CLEAN Makeup Manual for Sensitive Eyes.

Ready for Relief? Book Your Eye Exam Today!

The best way to protect your vision and wear makeup comfortably is to get personalized advice. A comprehensive eye exam can uncover the root cause of your sensitivity.

If you’re tired of struggling with makeup irritation, it’s time to consult an expert. Schedule your eye exam at Eyes in Disguise in the heart of Cow Hollow. Dr. Michelle Blas and her team on Union St are ready to help you see and feel your best. Book your appointment online today!

Love these tips? Follow us on Instagram for more eye care advice, beauty hacks, and expert insights.

Close-up of a blue eye with long eyelashes.

FAQs

Q: Why are my eyes so sensitive to makeup?

A: Eye sensitivity to makeup can be caused by several factors, including allergies to specific ingredients (like fragrances and preservatives), clogged oil glands along the eyelid, or using expired products that have grown bacteria. An eye exam can help determine the specific cause of your irritation.

Q: What is the best type of makeup for sensitive eyes?

A: For sensitive eyes, it's best to choose products that are labeled hypoallergenic,fragrance-free, and ophthalmologist-tested. Cream-based eyeshadows are often less irritating than powders because they produce less fallout.

Q: How often should I replace my eye makeup to prevent irritation?

A: To prevent bacteria buildup, you should replace your mascara and liquid eyeliner every three months. Cream and powder eyeshadows should be replaced every 12 to 24 months.

Q: Can an optometrist in San Francisco help with makeup sensitivity?

A: Yes. A comprehensive eye exam with an optometrist likeDr. Michelle Blas at Eyes in Disguise can identify underlying conditions like dry eye or blepharitis that contribute to makeup sensitivity. They can provide personalized advice and treatment options.

Back to Blog